Showing posts with label Religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Religion. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

"Ground Zero Mosque" - What ‘s Wrong With What’s Going On


Here’s what ‘s wrong with what’s going on about the “Ground Zero Mosque.” 

The State, so far – and the Marooned Astronaut hates having to keep adding that caveat – has done nothing to bar the Park 51 project, so that’s not the problem. Only someone who was one taco short of a combination platter would think the bigots who have always been vocally distrustful of Muslim’s wouldn’t weigh in on the dark side of this groundless (not even Ground Zero) controversy. So, as ugly as those hate mongers are upon the ear, it’s not that either.

It’s the people and organizations who usually act as protectors of and advocates for tolerance, civil liberties and basic human rights, but who now have come down on the wrong side of this thing that make me shiver, and should make us all tread lightly. I’m speaking about a number of individuals I know personally and some public figures and institutions I have observed in the media.  I will use one (to me the most chilling example) to illustrate my point of concern.

The Anti Defamation League.  The ADL is an outspoken watchdog organization, who has for decades vigilantly fought anti-Semitism and stood unflaggingly at the side of any group who is victimized by, or is prone to fall prey to, social injustice based upon race, religion, creed, etc.

Until now.

Back on July 28 of this year, they weighed in ( http://www.adl.org/PresRele/CvlRt_32/5820_32.htm ), firmly and clearly, with their take on the wisdom and propriety of the Park 51 project.  They said, “… ultimately this is not a question of rights, but a question of what is right. In our judgment, building an Islamic Center in the shadow of the World Trade Center will cause some victims more pain - unnecessarily - and that is not right,” and that, "… the controversy which has emerged regarding the building of an Islamic Center at this location is counterproductive to the healing process."

Even as they decried how, “…the bigotry some have expressed in attacking [the folks behind Park 51] is unfair, and wrong,” they parroted the propaganda of those very bigots, saying, “we are mindful that some legitimate questions have been raised about who is providing the funding to build it...”  No.  This is demonstrably not the case, and (so) not the point.  It is a bigot’s talking point.

There are lots of clever ways to punch holes in their statement. One could argue, yes, it is true: “It is not right that Park 51 cause victims more pain,” meaning that victims don’t have a right to feel pain at seeing Park 51. But I never would do that. An old friend once told me, (Maxim #18) “You can’t help what you like.”  And you can’t help what causes you emotional pain (generally speaking). So I can’t say that victims MUST NOT feel pain when they see an Islamic Center in the vicinity of Ground Zero, or anywhere. I might suggest that pain at seeing such an establishment is misplaced. But I would never deny their pain, its inherent validity, nor their right to feel it.

But I could never condone it preventing a community of peaceful fellow Americans from legally installing a facility wherein they intend to engage in their culture and observe their religion freely. 

I’m just one guy. People who argue against Park 51 on these grounds of avoiding pain for victims of 9/11 are wrong, and it is my choice to tell them so.  The ADL is an organization.  Unlike me, it doesn’t have a choice where to come down on such issues. It has a charter and a steering body of individuals, all bound to adhere to the ADL’s stated principles.  While I have a personal policy on religious intolerance, the ADL is a policy, focused entirely on this very matter.  Here is their 1913 mission statement (direct from their website, http://www.adl.org/about.asp?s=topmenu ):

“The immediate object of the League is to stop, by appeals to reason and conscience and, if necessary, by appeals to law, the defamation of the Jewish people. Its ultimate purpose is to secure justice and fair treatment to all citizens alike and to put an end forever to unjust and unfair discrimination against and ridicule of any sect or body of citizens.”

Since 1913, they EXIST to end unjust discrimination and ridicule of ANY SECT or BODY OF CITIZENS. Their words.  Not mine.

Sara Palin and Newt Gingrich can say whatever they want about Park 51. Their job descriptions are not specific on how they should view the issue. But the ADL is different. The ADL exists to come down on the right side of issues like this, particularly and especially when everyone else is on the wrong side.

And they blew it.  Big time.  Their transgression is not simply one of craven negligence, not one of merely failing to rise to the occasion in their self-appointed role as guardian of tolerance and diversity.  Their July 28 statement starts out admirably enough: “We regard freedom of religion as a cornerstone of the American democracy, and that freedom must include the right of all Americans – Christian, Jewish, Muslim, and other faiths – to build community centers and houses of worship.  We categorically reject appeals to bigotry on the basis of religion, and condemn those whose opposition to this proposed Islamic Center is a manifestation of such bigotry.”  They should have left it at that. Period. Or said nothing. 

Saying nothing would have constituted a mere a dereliction of their bound duty.  But the full statement, which comes down squarely (albeit in milquetoast fashion) on the side of fear and bigotry, is a willful betrayal of it.

Hence the reason I am more concerned, even frightened, about this stupid, issueless issue than I ever expected I would be.  The ADL was one of those “go to” places for minorities – usually Jewish, but their mission statement clearly once promised succor and protection to all peoples – when they felt ridiculed, when they felt discriminated against, when they felt in danger.  Sure, there are other places, other institutions whose stated commitment to social justice are of the same ilk. But there is no saying that this breathtaking erosion of integrity and core principles is limited just to ADL.

We now find ourselves in world where, perhaps, any organization such as ADL can be expected to carelessly jettison its commitment to protect those most threatened by the bigots against diversity. And I am left wondering, where am I to go? What if that day comes when my legally-proposed cultural building inspires actual public debate over whether I should be allowed to express my convictions of faith legally, as and where I choose? Where is this Marooned Astronaut to go now when public discourse waxes venal and rails against me and my breed; when bigots start feeling comfortable publicly proposing my expulsion from the land, or at least from my rights, even though I am a US Citizen, just because of the strange-looking place in which I socialize, or the weird extraterrestrial complexion of my skin, or the alien language I speak among my kin, or my Jewish heritage.  Who should I count on, now that I know it cannot be the ADL?

Saturday, August 28, 2010

Thank God the 10 Commandments are Against the Law

Maxim #13:Taken as a whole, the Ten Commandments would be unconstitutional as laws in the United States of America and are demonstrably NOT the basis of American law and society.

Here’s one of the Marooned Astronaut’s favorite quotes from that supreme venal imbecile, Sarah Palin, uttered during her appearance back in May on Bill O’Reilly’s The O’reilly Factor:  “Go back to what our founders and our founding documents meant– they’re quite clear– that we would create law based on the God of the Bible and the Ten Commandments, it’s quite simple.”

Here’s a theory on why Sarah Palin cut and ran from her job serving the people of Alaska as governor: she woke up one morning and realized she was grossly incompetent in the duties of that office. The above quote is a case in point.

In the United States of America, it is against the law to base any law on the God of the Bible and the Ten Commandments.  This IS actually quite simple.  And it shows that Sarah Palin is so impaired of reason that she should not be allowed to operate heavy machinery (such as a snowmobile); and certainly not handle a firearm.

Let’s not focus on the entire bible.  You are busy and have things to do.  Let’s just take the Ten Commandments as a telltale example.  There are other sites that explain in depth how, as a whole, they are UnAmerican on principle.  I’ll do a quick summation. But first, let’s refresh ourselves on the text of the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America:

“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”  (Mmm.  Every time a read it or hear it, it’s like my sense of justice and affection for humanity take a jacuzzi.)

Now, let’s take a look at those Ten Commandments, one at a time:

1. “I am the Lord thy god; thou shalt have no other god before me.”
A person may BELIEVE this and may SPEAK about it all they want.  But it cannot be made the law of the land. It would establish a religion. The first commandment, as a law, is unconstitutional.

2. “Thou shalt not worship graven images.”
This can’t be a constitutional law as it blatantly reverses the “free exercise thereof” clause. If I want to worship a Campbell’s soup can, in America I am entitled to do so BY LAW.  If I want to worship a god named GOD SUCKS!, I may do so freely. So, commandment number 2, as a law, is unconstitutional.

3. “Thou shalt not take the name of the lord in vain.”
God dammit! Jesus fucking Christ, sideways on a popsicle stick! What effing Yahweh motherfuckin’ Jehovah said THAT was supposed to be a law?  None, as evidenced by the fact that the thought police are not kicking down my door right now.  Commandment number 3, were it law, would be a blatant violation of the “freedom of speech” clause of the first amendment.  The third commandment, as a law, is unconstitutional.

4. “Remember the Sabbath day and keep it holy.”
The fact that on both Saturday (the actual biblical Sabbath) and Sunday (the Sabbath as revised by Christians) I can go out and hire just about anybody to do any job I want (that is, if the Marooned Astronaut actually had any real money), including strippers (I have seen it done), shows that this is not actually the law of the land.  The fact that it would constitute the establishment of a religion means that it can never be the law of the land until the Constitution is overturned and burned.  The 4th commandment, as a law, is unconstitutional.

5. “Honor thy father and thy mother.”
This one’s a push.  Technically, it is not illegal. But it is also sure no law in the United States of America. Let’s put a dash through the score box on #5: a 50/50 split.

6.  “Thou shalt not commit murder.”
Well, nothing unconstitutional here.  Murder (so far as I know) is illegal, without challenge, in the lower 48 plus Alaska, Hawaii and all the territories and protectorates.  Yay!  The Bible gets up on the scoreboard.  You go, God.  It’s your birthday! Its your… eesh. (Incidentally, the written injunction against murder predates the Mosaic “Big Ten.” It is found, among other places, in the code of Hammurabi in 1790 BC and in the code of Ur-Nammu in 2100 BC. The 10 Commandments are thought to originate no earlier than 1450 BC. As an unwritten law, I’d say it’s been considered a pretty good idea ever since two people lived near each other.  Say, between 10,000 and 1,000,000 years before the Bible.)

7. “Thou shalt not commit adultery.”
While it once was Illegal in many states (just like harboring escaped slaves), it is no longer against the law. So, though it is not strictly unconstitutional, it does not appear in the foundation of law that holds up our society today. Just ask many of the politicians who love the Ten Commandments but who are also guilty of adultery and are not in jail.

8. "Thou shalt not steal."
Score one, God.

9.  "Thou shalt not bear false witness."
BIG score here.  Not because it’s more important than murder or stealing, but because it’s subtler, and a lesser god (say, Kthulhu or Baal or Satan) might have missed it.

10. "Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor’s shit."
Okay.  Forgetting that this is unenforceable, it is not strictly unconstitutional.  However, it is decidedly UN-American. The United States of America is a consumerist, capitalist free market economy. It is predicated on consumers knowing what their neighbors have and wanting to possess those self same luxuries.  The media universe which defines and bounds our modern society is utterly subsidized by advertising dollars, dollars spent to elicit one’s envy of his and her neighbor’s shit. If #10 were law and were enforceable, the day after it was ratified, every last trade group and industry in the nation would have their lobbyists in Washington working for its repeal, and the court cases would instantly pile high as the sky, based on a quite-valid claim of restraint of free trade. In any case, this commandment has no analog in the law of the land, nor in the constitution.  It is the foundation of nothing in this country.

So, here’s the final score. From among the Ten Commandments:

3 are actual law.

1 is neither legal nor illegal (the father/mother thing).

2 are decidedly NOT law; and

4 are blatantly unconstitutional. 

As a document, the Ten Commandments cannot be found in the foundation, or the roof, of our laws.  Period.

The Ten Commandments are not the law of this land.  They are not the “basis” for the law of this land.  They are PROTECTED by the law of this land, and thank Satan (or whoever – the Marooned Astronaut really doesn’t get you guys and this whole religion thing) for that.  Because you cannot make the Ten Commandments law without instituting a religion. And the moment the law against instituting a religion goes out the window, the law against the prohibition of the free exercise thereof goes with it. 

The next time you’re watching the news and some politician remarks offhandedly that the Ten Commandments and/or the Bible (and we’ll have another post looking at just what’s unconstitutional about the rest of the Bible, were it law) is/are the basis for America’s system of law, tell everyone watching with you this is just demonstrably wrong.  Even if you are watching by yourself.

Oh, yeah, and Sarah Palin?  You’re a moron.

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

WWJC

Back at the end of June, in response to the Supreme Court overturning Washington, D.C.’s handgun ban with their District of Columbia v. Heller ruling, NRA chief lobbyist Chris W. Cox mentioned that, “All law-abiding Americans have a fundamental, God-given right to defend themselves…”  Without getting into one of Cox’s numerous and exhaustive scholarly dissertations upon how a non-law-abiding American forfeits any of his or her rights as granted by God, or whether (and why) non-Americans are denied the benefit of such divine fiat, the Marooned Astronaut has been thinking a lot about God’s specific take on arms for personal defense and to wonder how the Deity might express this, His own given right, were He ever to walk the Earth in human form.

I began to wonder, in essence:



This artist’s impression depicts Jesus wielding a suppressed Glock 17 9mm parabellum, as described in the Gospel according to Luke. 

As so often is the case, biblical sources are not unanimous on the Lamb of God’s preferred sidearm.  The Gospel according to Matthew is quite specific, “And seeing the multitudes, he went up into a mountain, and carried there, and did conceal in the midst of his loins, yea, even unto his very thigh, a Walther PPK, inserted within a garter of black.” (Matthew 5:1-2)  While Mark is somewhat less explicit, he makes over 70 references to Jesus wielding a firearm of unspecified manufacture: “Jesus entered the temple area and began driving out those who were buying and selling there with his gat.” (Mark 11:15)

There has been much scholarly speculation over the reason Jesus is not reported to have been carrying on the day of the Crucifixion, though a prevailing school of thought suggests he was torn with indecision whether to go “old school” with a Colt .45 ACP Model 1911 or “heavy” with his now-famous S&W Model 29 .44 magnum. Medieval and Renaissance depictions of the Crucifixion showing Christ packing a Colt .44 single action Army “Peacemaker”* (as seen in “Christ on the Cross,” El Greco, 1600) are almost certainly apocryphal and were most likely intended as allegory.


* - Credit to renowned Neoclassical Art Historian P. Gorkin for this excellent citation.

Monday, August 23, 2010

The "Mosque" "at" Ground Zero, Installment #1

First, some housekeeping.  I know the images pasted into my last post are not appearing.  This is simply because Earthling blog tech is still in its infancy and I shall remedy it as soon as I figure out what I’m doing wrong.

Now, new topic.  The “mosque” (which is not a mosque) “at” (though it is nowhere in sight of) Ground Zero, item #11 on the growing list.

On my home planet, one of our founding laws states that the government “…shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof…  …or the right of the people peaceably to assemble...”  It is probably why I think the first amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America is such a nifty thing (see post #1).  On my planet, this is a precious, jealously guarded right.  It is treated as if it were impossibly fragile because so often in our history, as I gather is also the case in your world, it has proven so easy to destroy.  Children on my world of all creeds are taught from a very young age to react to any threat to anyone’s, even a stranger’s, rights to freedom of religion and peaceful assembly as if that threat were made to them personally.  For, at least on my planet, and certainly among all the astronauts serving aboard all its spaceships, we understand that we hold all our lives in each other’s hands; that, if I do not zealously defend my fellow citizen’s and crewmate’s basic inalienable rights, I should have no expectation that anyone will protect mine.

I have recently had the opportunity to correspond with someone, an Earth woman, about the hubbub downtown.  While acknowledging that legally there is nothing she can do to stop the planned installation of the Musilm Park 51 cultural center two blocks (and around a corner) from Ground Zero, she insists that the commitment to go through with the building is “tacky” and that “They” are being inconsiderate of  “us” (she actually uses these words) and our sensitivities in the aftermath of 9/11.

When pressed, she claims that she harbors no ill will towards Muslim’s per se.  However, she insists that a Muslim center 2 blocks (forget that you can’t even see it) from Ground Zero would pose an affront to anyone who suffered loss in that calamity.  She suggests that 10 blocks might be a minimum distance to contemplate such a center, but implies that no matter where it was placed, it would rub salt in our national wounds. Had she the ability to do so, she would tell “Them” not to build where they intend to build.  Because they are Muslim.

Forgetting the numerous ways in which these positions are offensive, contradictory and, in part, nonsensical, I could not help think of a scenario parents use to teach young children on my world the basic meaning of religious tolerance.  I’ll rephrase here using the particulars of this situation.

Keep in mind (as I mentioned) that we all hold each other’s lives in our hands, and that this blade cuts both ways.  If you are among the many, many people who acknowledge the Park 51 group have a legal right to build at 45-41 Park Place, but who support – even if only in words – the campaign to make them move from the location, you may, today, indeed succeed in intimidating, coercing or cajoling the project into going elsewhere.  But what happens when, some day, your basic rights, or your very life, or the rights and/or lives of your children, depend on the goodwill of a Muslim?  When some loud majority of strangers of another faith try to stop you from having your house of worship in place X because they find it offensive, how will you explain your actions of today to the Muslim neighbor you may then desperately depend on for help?  Will you be able to say, “Hey, friend, remember when I had your back down at Park 51?  I need your help now.”? 

On my planet, every Muslim knows that he or she has a right… a RIGHT… to expect me to hide them in my basement to be safe from ethnic or religious violence.  And I know I enjoy that same right among them. I ask you, Earthling, when they come for you, and the only door you find belongs to a Muslim whom you told today, “Move your mosque where it doesn’t offend my sensibilities,” will you have the temerity to knock and demand safe haven?  They may offer it to you, but I’m not sure you will have the right to expect it.